Google has as soon as once more prevailed in an ongoing criminal struggle with the music lyrics site Genius. Back in 2019, Genius claimed that Google was once the use of its transcribed lyrics with out permission in seek effects.
Genius has a big database of music lyrics, and considers itself as “the arena’s greatest song encyclopedia.” It attempted to display that Google was once scraping information from its site by way of hanging watermarks on its lyrics. It then gave the impression in Google searches however with none hyperlink again or attribution to Genius.
Google Wins Court Battle with Genius over Song Lyrics
Google mentioned that it didn’t “move slowly or scrape web pages to supply” music lyrics. Canadian lyrics licensing web site LyricFind, additionally a defendant within the Genius lawsuit, licenses its lyric transcriptions to Google.
Judge Margo Brodie dominated in August 2020 that whilst Genius’ claims of scraping gave the impression credible, they didn’t represent a copyright violation since Genius isn’t the true copyright holder of the lyrics, which she mentioned belonged to the musicians who wrote them. Genius licenses the lyrics, including to them via by-product works comparable to annotations, however Brodie mentioned that didn’t give Genius possession over the true lyrics themselves.
On Thursday, a three-judge panel within the 2d Circuit affirmed the sooner determination. They mentioned that the lyrics are secure by way of copyrights that Genius doesn’t personal.
See Also: Google’s CTO envisions extra gross sales of tablets than laptops
Source: The Verge